SESSION OF 1999
SUPPLEMENTAL NOTE ON
SUBSTITUTE FOR HOUSE BILL NO. 2405
As Amended by House Committee of the Whole
Brief(1)
The bill would amend existing law regarding parental involvement when a minor seeks an abortion and amend a child abuse
statute to add judges, licensed master's level psychologists, and
licensed professional counselors to the list of persons required to
report child abuse or neglect. Judges who suspect or determine
that a pregnant minor utilizing the judicial by-pass procedure prior
to an abortion has been sexually abused would be required to
report those suspicions or determinations to SRS.
Existing law regarding abortions would be amended as
follows:
- The written consent of one parent or guardian, or a court-ordered waiver of the consent requirement, would be necessary prior to performance of an abortion on an unemancipated
pregnant minor. Under current law, a pregnant minor's
parent or guardian must receive from the doctor written
notice of intent to perform an abortion, unless the judicial by-pass procedure is used.
- The only grounds for an emergency abortion without parental
consent would be a threat to the pregnant minor's life. Under
existing law, an abortion can be performed without parental
notification if the abortion is necessitated by an emergency
that threatens the woman's health, safety, or well being.
- Parental consent would not be required if the minor's parent
was responsible for the pregnancy or the doctor determines
an emergency exists that threatens the life of the minor as to
require an abortion.
- The judicial by-pass could be sought by any pregnant minor
who objects to obtaining parental consent or if consent has
been denied by the parent. The judicial by-pass procedure in
existing law would not be changed.
- The list of information that must be included in reports of
abortions under current law would be amended to include the
number of abortions performed under the auspices of a court
order issued as a result of the judicial by-pass procedure and
the number of abortions performed with parental consent.
- The definitions of "counselor" and "qualified person" would
both be amended to include master's level psychologists and
to correct the titles of counselors and marriage and family
therapists. Those definitions are used in the provisions of the
abortion law regarding counseling of a minor prior to abortion
and the Women's Right to Know Act.
- A definition of "parent" would be included in the abortion
law. A parent would be the parent of the pregnant female
minor or the guardian of such minor.
- The definition of "viable" would be amended to make
applicable to the entire act the definition enacted in 1998 and
currently applicable to only the post-viability abortion provisions. That definition would include as viable for purposes of
the abortion laws any fetuses that have a reasonable probability of living outside the mother's womb with natural or
artificial life support. Under current law viable fetuses are
only those capable of survival outside the uterus without the
application of extraordinary medical means.
Background
The original bill was supported during a hearing before the
House Committee on Federal and State Affairs by Representative
Hutchins and a representative of Kansans For Life. Opponents of
the bill included the Kansas Choice Alliance, the Greater Kansas
City Section of the National Council of Jewish Women, the
League of Women Voters, Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri, Right to Life of Kansas, and Kansas members of the
National Organization of Women. Written testimony in opposition
to the bill was submitted by a social worker from Hays.
The House Committee amended the bill by introducing a
substitute bill that would insert the parental consent requirement
in the existing statutory framework for parental notification.
The House Committee of the Whole amended the bill to:
- include certain mental health professionals in the list of
persons required to report child abuse or neglect;
- amend the definitions of counselor and qualified person;
- add reports of abortions performed with parental consent;
- delete the requirement that the physician assume certain
costs when abortions are performed under auspices of a court
order; and
- delete the definition of fetus.
1. *Supplemental notes are prepared by the Legislative Research
Department and do not express legislative intent. The supplemental
note and fiscal note for this bill may be accessed on the Internet at
http://www.ink.org/public/legislative/bill_search.html